From the archive

Can you be fit and fat?

March 22, 2011

I was finishing up dinner tonight when my phone rang. I looked at the caller ID thing and realized it was my buddy Steve, the one we call the Jewish Rambo here at Vinnie’s Blog and Country Club. We chatted about meaningless stuff for a while, then he said, “I haven’t seen a blog from you lately. What’s the matter?” I reminded Steve that we put up something new every day on the blog. Beside Andy’s Recipes, we also put up items from around the internet. I guess he forgets I have a day job. We went on to talk about a few other things. Before we got off the phone, I told Steve to throw out a subject for my next blog. The phone went silent for a few seconds. Then he uttered these words: “Can a person be both fit and fat?” The example he gave was a lineman in the NFL. I told you that to tell you this. I’ve defined fitness before on this blog, but it’s always good to define it again. I mean, what does “fit” really mean? It means “fit” to do the activity at hand. An example is a fit swimmer. If you get caught in a flood or get thrown from a boat, you have a greater chance of survival than a person who is a fit jogger who never swims. Getting back to the NFL. The guy who is fit to play on the line is not fit to be a running back or wide receiver. Each position is a specialty position. The wide receiver has to be fast and nimble. A lineman needs to have quick feet and enough girth to stop opposing linemen. To this point, I think the NFL is running into a real problem, not to add to the problems it already has. But I digress. The average lineman during the first Super Bowl in the late 1960s weighed around 240 pounds. Remember Jerry Kramer and the boys? The average lineman now tips the scales at over 300 pounds. These guys are literally becoming sumo wrestlers without the fancy diaper. Is it healthy? Hell no. As a matter of fact I saw a report on this on Bryant Gumbel’s Real Sports. Some of these guys die before they reach 50. Under Vinnie’s definition of whether you can be fit and fat at the same time, I say yes. And yes I used myself in the third person. Will a fat person have the same quality of life and longevity as their thin counterparts? I think the answer is definitely no.

Fitness Confidential Podcast

Keep Listening

Vinnie talks about this every week on the Fitness Confidential podcast. Start with the newest episodes.

October 26, 2026

Avoiding the Grift – Episode 2871

Episode 2871: Vinnie Tortorich and Anna Vocino discuss avoiding the grift behind influencers, marketing, and false […]

October 22, 2026

Live from Jaspr House – Episode 2870

Episode 2873: Vinnie Tortorich and Jaspr founder Mike Feldstein discuss clean indoor air, building a business […]

October 21, 2026

Zero Resistance Life – Episode 2869

Episode 2869: Vinnie Tortorich and Chris Shaffer discuss road trip NSNG®, doctors learning about low-carb, and […]

Join the email list

Bring Vinnie your question

Live call-in show invites, straight talk on what's actually working, and first word when NSNG® VIP opens.

A few emails a month. Unsubscribe anytime.

Guided Workouts

No-BS workouts for people who want results without spending their lives in the gym or falling for the latest fitness scam

Documentaries

Hard-hitting films that cut through the propaganda, follow the money, and tell the truth about what’s making people sick

NSNG® VIP

Where No Sugar, No Grains becomes a lifestyle, with coaching, community, and tools to keep you consistent long term.

Pure Vitamin Club

High-quality, no-nonsense supplements and coffee made without fillers, gimmicks, or hidden ingredients. Just what your body actually needs.

Become a SuperFan
Book a phone consult with Vinnie
Get the book Fitness Confidential