From the archive

Dr. Ian Smith Bashed Me On Opie And Anthony

February 22, 2014

The Diet Games

I love contests. I love competing. It’s the fiber of my being.

I started playing sports as a young man. I still compete in 5Ks, 10Ks, ultra bike racing, skeet shooting, and trap.

No one would ever say I would shy away from a competition.

But there is one kind that I find deplorable. It’s when people compete to lose weight.

contest

A prime example of this would be the biggest loser, and shows like it.

Inadvertently, I found myself in the middle of a weight loss competition. The funny thing is, I didn’t know I was in it. It just kind of happened.

Let me explain. Ian Smith was pushing some crappy diet plan on the Opie and Anthony Show, a nationally-syndicated program.

To prove that his diet works, he got two producers to compete with each other for one month for a prize of $500.

All these gentlemen had to do was live on his pre-packaged food for thirty days. The one who lost the most weight would win.

Ian Smith predicted they would each lose at least twenty pounds.

Within one week, both felt like the Ian Smith plan was impossible to follow. It was based on calorie in, calorie out. The food was crappy, and the exercise program wasn’t suitable for such overweight guys.

One contestant, Roland Campos, happened to grab my book after hearing comedian Bobby Kelly rave about the weight he lost upon reading Fitness Confidential.

Roland realized he should abandon the competition and start eating right.

You can only imagine how upset Ian Smith was about this, literally going on the show and bashing me…a guy he’s never met.

So, laughingly, Ian told the guy if he continued on my diet, he would only gain weight.

The contest ended on Friday. The guy who followed the advice from Fitness Confidential lost 24 pounds (doing little exercise and not feeling hungry once). The producer following Ian’s diet only lost 11 pounds and admitted to struggling to stay on the diet, claiming he was starving all the time and felt perfectly miserable.

That didn’t stop Ian from bashing me again, along with a lot of backpedaling.

I’m happy that Roland lost weight, and I hope he continues to eat right. To be perfectly honest, I don’t give a shit about winning the competition. As I said, I don’t believe in it.

Here’s what I’m offering you. Anyone who buys a copy of Fitness Confidential over the next 14 days and leaves a review on Amazon will be eligible for a prize. I will pick my favorite review and offer that person a one-hour phone consultation…no weight loss contest involved.

Fitness Confidential Podcast

Keep Listening

Vinnie talks about this every week on the Fitness Confidential podcast. Start with the newest episodes.

October 21, 2026

Zero Resistance Life – Episode 2869

Episode 2869: Vinnie Tortorich and Chris Shaffer discuss road trip NSNG®, doctors learning about low-carb, and […]

October 19, 2026

AI Faux Influencers – Episode 2868

Episode 2868: Vinnie Tortorich and Anna Vocino discuss the health and fitness spectrum, including misinformation from […]

October 16, 2026

Obesity Science with Gary Taubes – Episode 2867

Episode 2867: Vinnie Tortorich and health science author Gary Taubes discuss the history of obesity science […]

Join the email list

Bring Vinnie your question

Live call-in show invites, straight talk on what's actually working, and first word when NSNG® VIP opens.

A few emails a month. Unsubscribe anytime.

Guided Workouts

No-BS workouts for people who want results without spending their lives in the gym or falling for the latest fitness scam

Documentaries

Hard-hitting films that cut through the propaganda, follow the money, and tell the truth about what’s making people sick

NSNG® VIP

Where No Sugar, No Grains becomes a lifestyle, with coaching, community, and tools to keep you consistent long term.

Pure Vitamin Club

High-quality, no-nonsense supplements and coffee made without fillers, gimmicks, or hidden ingredients. Just what your body actually needs.

Become a SuperFan
Book a phone consult with Vinnie
Get the book Fitness Confidential